8241 MAIN Street

Estimated monthly payment

$9,854 /mo

Principal and interest only, based on $375,000 down (20%), a 6.875% 30-year fixed rate. Property taxes, homeowners insurance, and the $200/mo HOA are not included.

Listing Snapshot

Price

$1,875,000

Days on Site

64 Days

Bedrooms

4

Total Baths

5

Full Baths

5

Partial Baths

0

Living Area

3,200 sqft

Total Sq Ft

4,968 sqft

Lot Size

0.32 Acres

Year Built

1914

Property Type

Single Family

MLS #

B26063000

Property Tax

$8,871 (2025)

HOA Fees

$200 / Monthly

Subdivision

KREAMERS

Development

Seagull Bay Charlotte Harbor

County

Lee

Status

Active

Special Conditions

Auction

About This Property

PUBLIC PRICING AUCTION - BIDDING IS EXTENDED UNTIL OCTOBER 17, 2026. List price is the minimum qualified bid of $1,875,000, determined by the public. View the terms of this sale and the process before bidding. A rare asset with many possibilities - waterfront estate, retreat, investment, or short-term rental. This historic estate blends early-1900s character with over $1 MILLION in high-end upgrades, and qualifies for 100% bonus depreciation on FF&E values. Located on the northern tip of Pine Island, where the views simply do not get better. Water views from nearly every window, and the primary suite has panoramic views of Charlotte Harbor. With 2 BOAT SLIPS and lift access, entry into Charlotte Harbor and the Gulf is quick and easy. Some properties are easy to describe by bedrooms, bathrooms, square footage and comparable sales. 8241 Main Street is not one of them. Formerly known as the historic Bokeelia Tarpon Inn, this 4-bedroom, 5-bath waterfront estate on the northern end of Pine Island combines more than a century of Old Florida history with more than $1 million in improvements, restoration, design and modernization by the current owners. It may also be purchased turn-key, creating an unusual opportunity for a buyer who wants to begin enjoying the property without first undertaking years of renovation and furnishing. What makes 8241 Main Street particularly difficult to duplicate is not any single feature. It is the combination of history, waterfront setting, artistic character, boating access, privacy, flexibility and location within one of Southwest Florida's most distinctive island environments. HISTORY AND SETTING The home dates to 1914 and has evolved through generations of Pine Island history. Its identity has long been connected to Bokeelia's fishing heritage and the extraordinary waters surrounding the north end of the island. Today the residence retains the character and proportions of an earlier Florida while incorporating extensive modern improvements designed for comfort, resiliency and everyday use. The setting is exceptional. From the northern end of Pine Island, the property enjoys expansive water views, including panoramic views toward Charlotte Harbor from the primary suite. Water can be seen from many areas of the residence, creating a constant visual relationship between the home and the surrounding coastal environment. For boaters and anglers, the location opens into an extraordinary Southwest Florida water system. The property includes two boat slips with lift access and provides boating connections into the Charlotte Harbor, Matlacha Pass and greater Pine Island Sound region, with access toward Boca Grande, Cayo Costa, North Captiva, Captiva and the Gulf. This is an area whose fishing history stretches back generations and remains internationally associated with tarpon and some of Florida's most celebrated inshore and coastal fishing. THE RESIDENCE The experience begins before entering the home. The grand covered front area creates a natural place to sit, entertain, enjoy coastal breezes and take in the waterfront surroundings. Throughout the property, historic character has been preserved while new improvements have been incorporated with unusually thoughtful attention to materials and design. The gourmet kitchen is a centerpiece rather than simply a functional room. It features a Big Chill refrigerator and Big Chill Classic gas range, unlacquered brass hardware, a designer Zephyr ventilation hood with commercial-grade baffle system, brass pot filler, soapstone countertops and full-height soapstone backsplash, custom solid-wood cabinetry, glass-front upper cabinets, a custom integrated drainboard sink, restored antique pantry door, period-inspired leaded-glass transom and classic herringbone brick flooring. The principal living areas are bright, open and filled with natural light. Porcelain tile flooring and a Touchstone built-in electric fireplace complement the home's historic architecture without attempting to disguise its age or character. Upstairs, solid-wood floors and custom hardwood stair treads continue the traditional feel of the residence. The expansive primary suite includes vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, decorative beam detailing, panoramic water views and a built-in electric fireplace. The spa-inspired primary bathroom includes water-jet-cut marble mosaic tile, a freestanding soaking tub, Kingston Brass floor-mounted tub filler with hand shower, custom solid-wood cabinetry and thoughtfully selected finishes intended to feel more like a private retreat than an ordinary residential bathroom. SYSTEMS, STRUCTURE AND PROTECTION The improvements extend well beyond finishes and decoration. Major property features include: • Metal roof • Two A/C systems • Spray-foam insulation • Walkable attic with additional storage • Navien high-efficiency tankless water heater • Permanently installed Generac standby generator • HOOT aerobic wastewater treatment system • Impact-resistant windows • Electric hurricane protection throughout the home • Kevlar hurricane protection for the upstairs lanai • James Hardie shake siding • High-performance AZEK decking • New railings and stairs • Front deck supported by 24 new structural columns • Covered upstairs porch with tongue-and-groove pecky cypress ceiling • Custom-built pergola with electric • Two boat slips and boat-lift access The grounds are as individual as the residence. Mature landscaping includes fruit-bearing orange, lemon, lime, fig, blackberry and combination citrus trees, together with a substantial coral fountain, rose garden, landscape lighting and outdoor areas intended for relaxation and gathering. RANGE OF POSSIBLE USES Yet the physical improvements tell only part of the story. The possibilities for this property are unusually broad. A future purchaser may see it first as a distinctive private waterfront residence. Another may envision a multi-generational estate or legacy property. An entrepreneur may see a Florida base from which to live, work and entertain. A company or closely held business may see an executive residence or private corporate retreat. A hospitality-minded purchaser may see the property's historic identity and flexible configuration differently again. It may suit an artist, writer or creative professional seeking privacy and inspiration. It may suit the serious fisherman or boater who understands what proximity to Charlotte Harbor, Boca Grande Pass and the surrounding islands means. It may suit a naturalist, photographer or environmentally minded purchaser attracted to the mangroves, aquatic preserves, wildlife and comparatively undeveloped character of this part of Southwest Florida. And for someone relocating to Florida, the turn-key nature of the property presents another possibility: establish an immediate furnished waterfront residence while taking the time to determine what a permanent Florida lifestyle ultimately looks like. BOKEELIA AND PINE ISLAND Bokeelia itself is part of the opportunity. Located at the northern end of Pine Island, Bokeelia remains dramatically different from much of highly developed coastal Florida. The island is surrounded by an extraordinary combination of estuarine waters, mangrove systems, fishing grounds, protected aquatic environments and barrier islands. Pine Island Sound lies to the west and Matlacha Pass to the east, with Charlotte Harbor immediately associated with the island's northern end. This is an area where boating, fishing and nature are not amenities added by a developer. They are part of the geography and culture. Pine Island's relationship with these waters reaches back thousands of years. The Calusa built an extraordinarily sophisticated fishing-based society throughout Southwest Florida's estuarine environment. Pine Island remains home to important archaeological and environmental research, while the surrounding Pine Island Sound and Matlacha

General Features

Property Type

Single Family

Status

Active

Year Built

1914

Property Condition

Resale

Number of Stories

2

Levels

Two

Parking

Driveway / On Street

Direction Faces

North

Lot Size (Acres)

0.32

Living Sq Ft

3,200

Total Sq Ft

4,968

Structure Type

House

Sewer

Septic Tank

Water Source

Public

Zoning

RM-2

Interior Features

Appliances

Dryer / Dishwasher / Disposal / Microwave / Range / Refrigerator / Tankless Water Heater / Water Heater

Cooling

Central Air / Electric

Heating

Central / Electric

Flooring

Other

Fireplace

Yes

Interior Features

Other

Main Level Bedrooms

1

Main Level Baths

2

Total Rooms

10

Furnished

Negotiable

Exterior Features

Construction

Other

Roof

Metal

Exterior Features

Balcony / Outdoor Living Area

Architectural Style

Florida / Traditional

Patio & Porch

Covered / Patio / Balcony

Lot Features

Quarter To Half Acre Lot

Waterfront

Yes

Waterfront Features

Bayfront / No Fixed Bridges / Other

View

Bay / Water

Community & HOA

HOA Fee

$200 / Monthly

HOA Name

Seagull Bay Property Owner's Association

HOA Includes

Common Areas

Association Amenities

Boating / Trails

Community Features

Home Owners Association / Boat Facilities

Utilities

Cable Connected / Electricity Connected / Propane / Phone Connected / Water Connected

Pets Allowed

No Pet Restrictions / Pet Restrictions / Yes

Financing Terms

Cash / Conventional / Lease Purchase / Owner May Carry / Private Financing Available / Trust Deed

Restrictions

No Restrictions / Ok To Lease / Short Term Rentals Allowed

MLS Area

5940 - Other Florida County