Should I always take the highest offer?

No. The best offer is the highest net that will actually close by a date that works for you. A higher offer with a large credit, weak financing and many contingencies can be worth less than a lower, cleaner one.

How do I know if a buyer can actually close?

Look at the financing type, the quality of the pre-approval, the deposit size and how quickly it goes hard, and the contingencies. Have your agent speak to the lender directly, which reveals a great deal a letter does not.

What is the weakest term a buyer can include?

A contingency on the sale of their own home, because your transaction then depends on one you cannot see or control. Where you accept it, tighten everything else to compensate.

Do I have to accept the first offer?

No, and you can counter every offer you are prepared to work with rather than rejecting outright. An offer that opens low sometimes ends high, and a counter costs you nothing but a prompt reply.

How do I compare two offers fairly?

Ask for a net sheet on each. Once every offer is expressed as what you actually receive, with a closing date attached, the comparison becomes straightforward in a way it never is on headline price.

Is a cash offer always better?

It is more certain, because financing and the appraisal come out of the equation, and it usually comes at a discount. Whether the certainty is worth the difference depends on how much you need the sale to close on schedule.

Should I ask for proof of funds?

Yes, dated and showing sufficient available balance rather than a screenshot of a total. It is ordinary diligence before taking your property off the market for someone.

Should I counter on price or terms?

Frequently on terms, since deposit size, inspection period length and closing date are easier for a buyer to give than money and each of them reduces your risk of the sale unravelling.

How quickly should I respond to an offer?

The same day where you can, even if only to acknowledge it and say when you will answer properly. A buyer who has just written an offer is at their most committed, and silence is read as rejection.

Can I accept an offer and keep showing the house?

That depends on your contract and whether a backup arrangement is in place. Once under contract you generally have obligations to that buyer, so discuss it with your agent rather than assuming.

Reading an offer properly

Evaluating offers on price alone is how sellers end up back on the market in week five, having turned down the offer that would have closed. An offer is a package: a number, a set of conditions, a timeline and a buyer of some particular strength. The highest number is frequently not the best package, and the difference is measured in whether the sale actually happens.

Free Home Valuation

Every situation on this page comes down to a number: what the property is worth and what you would net. We will work both out from recent sales near you, at no cost.

What to look at beyond the number

The buyer's financing: cash, conventional, government-backed, or something else, each of which behaves differently.

The quality of their pre-approval, meaning whether a lender has reviewed documents or merely taken their word for it.

The earnest money deposit, its size and how quickly it becomes non-refundable, which is the clearest signal of commitment available.

The contingencies, which are the buyer's exits: inspection, financing, appraisal, association review and, worst of all, the sale of their own home.

The timeline, meaning the inspection period, the financing period and the closing date.

Any concessions requested, which come off your proceeds exactly as a price reduction of the same amount would.

Compare on net, not on price

Ask for a net sheet on each offer rather than comparing headline numbers, since it takes minutes and prevents an expensive misreading.

An offer at a higher price requesting a substantial closing cost credit can net less than a lower offer requesting none.

Who pays which title and transfer items varies and is negotiable, so two offers at the same price can allocate costs differently.

A requested home warranty, survey or repair allowance all reduce what you receive.

A closing date that suits you has real value if it saves you a month of carrying costs or an interim move.

Once every offer is expressed as a net figure with a date attached, the comparison becomes straightforward in a way it never is on price.

How likely is it to close

A cash offer with proof of funds is the most certain, because financing and the appraisal come out of the equation entirely.

A financed offer from a buyer whose lender has actually underwritten their file is close behind, and considerably stronger than a higher offer with a one-line pre-qualification.

A large deposit that goes hard quickly says the buyer expects to close and is prepared to lose money if they do not.

Few contingencies and short periods say the same thing.

A sale-of-home contingency is the weakest term you can accept, because your transaction now depends on one you cannot see or control.

A buyer stretching to the top of their approval is more fragile than one buying comfortably, and their lender's queue becomes your risk.

Reading the financing type

Cash removes the appraisal and the lender, though it does not remove title work or association steps.

Conventional financing is the most common and generally the most flexible on property condition.

Government-backed programs apply their own property condition standards, so a home needing work may generate repair requirements before closing.

That is a practical consideration rather than a reason to reject such an offer, and on a property in reasonable condition it makes very little difference.

A buyer using a specialist product may have a longer timeline, which is worth asking about rather than discovering.

The useful question is not which program but whether this particular buyer, with this lender, can close on this property by that date.

Verifying rather than assuming

Ask for proof of funds on a cash offer, dated and showing sufficient available balance rather than a screenshot of a total.

Ask for the pre-approval and ask whether the lender has reviewed income and asset documentation or only spoken to the buyer.

Have your agent speak to the lender directly, which is normal and which reveals a great deal that a letter does not.

Ask what the buyer's timeline actually depends on, since a buyer with a lease ending is more motivated and also more brittle.

Ask whether they have lost a previous contract and why, since the answer is frequently informative.

None of this is intrusive. It is the ordinary diligence of deciding which offer to take off the market for.

Countering well

Counter on the terms you actually want rather than only on price, since deposit, inspection period and closing date are frequently easier for a buyer to give than money.

Counter every offer you are prepared to work with rather than rejecting outright, because an offer that opens low sometimes ends high.

Be specific. A counter that says what you need and why is more likely to be met than one that simply restates a number.

Keep the timeline tight in your counter, since a shorter inspection period reduces the window in which the deal can unravel.

Where you concede on price, ask for something in return on terms.

Respond promptly. Buyers who have written an offer are engaged, and delay is the most reliable way to let that fade.

The offer to take

The best offer is the one with the highest net that will actually close by a date that works for you.

Where two offers are close on net, take the one with the stronger buyer and the fewer exits, essentially always.

Where one is meaningfully higher but visibly fragile, consider whether the difference compensates you for the risk of being back on the market in a month with a property that now looks stale.

A property that goes under contract and comes back attracts questions, and it frequently sells for less than it would have.

Where you accept a weaker offer for a higher price, tighten the terms to compensate: a larger deposit, shorter periods, a firmer financing position.

And keep the backup conversation open, since a second buyer who was told they were close is the person you want to call if the first one fails.

Timing your response

How quickly you respond to an offer affects the outcome more than sellers expect, because a buyer who has just written an offer is at their most committed.

Delay lets enthusiasm cool and lets a buyer keep looking, and buyers who keep looking find other properties.

Where you are waiting for another offer you have been told is coming, say so rather than going silent, because silence is read as rejection.

Where you need time to consider, a short and specific timeframe is far better than an open-ended pause.

Contracts generally include a deadline by which an offer must be accepted, and letting one lapse is a decision even when it was not intended as one.

The general rule is to respond the same day where you can, even if the response is only to acknowledge and give a time by which you will answer properly.

This page explains how the selling process works and what the market does with each decision. It is not legal or tax advice. Anything involving tax on your sale belongs with an accountant, and anything involving the contract's legal effect belongs with a Florida attorney. What we can give you is an accurate figure for what your home is worth and what you would net, which is the input every one of those conversations needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I always take the highest offer?: No. The best offer is the highest net that will actually close by a date that works for you. A higher offer with a large credit, weak financing and many contingencies can be worth less than a lower, cleaner one.
How do I know if a buyer can actually close?: Look at the financing type, the quality of the pre-approval, the deposit size and how quickly it goes hard, and the contingencies. Have your agent speak to the lender directly, which reveals a great deal a letter does not.
What is the weakest term a buyer can include?: A contingency on the sale of their own home, because your transaction then depends on one you cannot see or control. Where you accept it, tighten everything else to compensate.
Do I have to accept the first offer?: No, and you can counter every offer you are prepared to work with rather than rejecting outright. An offer that opens low sometimes ends high, and a counter costs you nothing but a prompt reply.
How do I compare two offers fairly?: Ask for a net sheet on each. Once every offer is expressed as what you actually receive, with a closing date attached, the comparison becomes straightforward in a way it never is on headline price.
Is a cash offer always better?: It is more certain, because financing and the appraisal come out of the equation, and it usually comes at a discount. Whether the certainty is worth the difference depends on how much you need the sale to close on schedule.
Should I ask for proof of funds?: Yes, dated and showing sufficient available balance rather than a screenshot of a total. It is ordinary diligence before taking your property off the market for someone.
What happens if I take an offer and it falls through?: You return to the market with a property that now attracts questions, and it frequently sells for less than it would have. That risk is exactly why certainty deserves weight against price.
Should I counter on price or terms?: Frequently on terms, since deposit size, inspection period length and closing date are easier for a buyer to give than money and each of them reduces your risk of the sale unravelling.
How quickly should I respond to an offer?: The same day where you can, even if only to acknowledge it and say when you will answer properly. A buyer who has just written an offer is at their most committed, and silence is read as rejection.
Can I accept an offer and keep showing the house?: That depends on your contract and whether a backup arrangement is in place. Once under contract you generally have obligations to that buyer, so discuss it with your agent rather than assuming.

Handling multiple offers

Multiple offers need a process rather than instinct. How to call for best terms, what to disclose, and how to keep a strong second buyer engaged.

Cash offer or financed offer?

A cash offer vs a financed offer is a trade of price against certainty. What cash actually removes, what it does not, and how to verify it.

What you actually walk away with

A seller net sheet shows proceeds after every cost, not the sale price. What comes out at closing in Florida and why the figure moves.

Work out your numbers

What is my home worth?

A valuation built from closed sales in your own community, with the comparables named.

Estimate your net proceeds

Work the commission, documentary stamps and closing costs against your own number.

Current market reports

Prices, days on market and inventory for the counties we cover, updated monthly.

How we list a home

What we do between the listing agreement and the closing table, phase by phase.

Talk It Through

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what it is worth

Most of what makes a sale complicated is solvable once somebody has looked at the actual numbers. Onias Derilus is a licensed Florida broker and there is no cost to a conversation, whether you list this month or next year.

Get My Home Value Buying Too? Start Here

Keep Reading