How accurate is a Zestimate?

Accuracy varies a great deal by area and property type, and the portals publish their own error figures. The useful figure is the error range rather than the median, because the properties where the model is least accurate tend to be exactly the ones that need careful pricing.

Why is my Zestimate lower than my agent's valuation?

Usually because the model cannot see condition, improvements or property-specific advantages. It works from public records, which do not record a renovated kitchen or a better view. Ask your agent to show the comparable sales behind their number so you can judge which is better supported.

Can I get my Zestimate changed?

You can claim the property on the portal and correct factual details such as bedroom count or square footage, which sometimes moves the estimate. You cannot have a number changed because you disagree with it. Correcting genuine record errors is worth doing regardless.

Should I price my home at the Zestimate?

No. It is a statistical estimate with a published error range, not an analysis of your property. Use it for rough orientation early on, then price from a comparative market analysis where you can see the sales and the adjustments.

Buyers keep citing the Zestimate. What do I say?

Show the comparable sales rather than arguing about the model. Evidence works where disputing the number does not, because a buyer reasonably discounts the seller's opinion. Having the package prepared before listing turns this into a short conversation.

Do appraisers use automated estimates?

No. An appraiser selects comparable sales and makes documented adjustments, much closer to a CMA than to a model. That is another reason to price from a CMA: it is the same method the appraisal will use, so it anticipates the constraint rather than colliding with it.

Which should I trust for a condo?

A CMA, by a wide margin. Automated models rarely capture building-specific factors such as pending assessments, reserve health, insurance difficulties or financing availability, and any of those can move a condo's value substantially. Those factors are exactly what a local analysis is for.

Why did my Zestimate change without anything happening?

Models update as new sales record nearby and as the underlying method is revised. A change usually reflects neighbourhood transactions rather than anything about your property. That is also why the trend over time is more informative than any single reading.

Should I worry if my Zestimate drops mid-listing?

Not in itself, though a buyer may raise it. The answer is the same as before: show the comparable sales rather than arguing about the model. A prepared package of recent sales settles the conversation faster than any explanation of how automated valuation works.

Do agents use automated estimates at all?

As a rough orientation when a seller first makes contact, and as a sense of what a buyer has probably already seen. Not to set a price. Any agent who agrees with an automated number without showing you their own comparable sales analysis has skipped the actual work.

Is a free online valuation the same as a CMA?

It depends entirely on what sits behind it. Some are automated estimates with a form attached. A genuine comparative market analysis names the sales it relies on, explains the adjustments and includes what is currently competing with you. Ask which you are being given.

Does an automated estimate affect my appraisal?

No. Appraisers select comparable sales and document adjustments, and they do not consult portal estimates. The estimate can affect buyer expectations and therefore the negotiation, which is a different problem and one that comparable sales evidence solves.

My neighbour has a higher estimate. Does that mean anything?

Only that the model read their property differently, often because of recorded square footage, bedroom count or a more recent nearby sale. It says nothing about what either property would actually sell for. Compare closed sales instead.

Zillow Zestimate vs a CMA: why they differ

Zillow Zestimate vs a CMA is a comparison between an automated estimate and a human analysis, and the two answer different questions. The Zestimate is a statistical model applied to public records at scale. A comparative market analysis is a person choosing the right comparable sales and adjusting them. Both are useful, and only one is built to price your specific property.

Free Home Valuation

Every situation on this page comes down to a number: what the property is worth and what you would net. We will work both out from recent sales near you, at no cost.

What an automated estimate is built from

Automated valuation models use public records, tax assessments, prior sale prices and whatever listing data is available, processed statistically across large areas.

They are good at identifying broad patterns and at producing a plausible number instantly for almost any address.

They are structurally blind to condition, because nothing in a public record says whether a kitchen was renovated or a roof is failing.

They are weak on features that do not appear in data, including views, orientation, noise, and which side of a community a unit sits on.

They lag the market, because they depend on recorded transactions that close weeks after the price was agreed.

Portals publish their own accuracy figures, and those figures are worth reading, particularly the error range rather than the headline median.

What a CMA is built from

A comparative market analysis starts by selecting sales a buyer would genuinely have considered instead of your property.

Each is adjusted for differences in size, condition, features and timing, with the adjustments defensible from evidence.

It includes properties currently on the market, because those are the alternatives a buyer can actually choose today.

It accounts for things no model can see: the assessment pending in your building, the busy road, the renovation you completed last year.

It produces a range with reasoning attached rather than a single number, which is more honest about how pricing works.

It is only as good as the person preparing it, which is the obvious weakness and the reason to ask to see the comparables.

Where the two diverge most

In communities with high turnover and similar units, the two tend to agree closely, because the model has plenty of clean data.

In neighbourhoods with varied properties and few recent sales, the model has little to work from and the gap widens sharply.

On a property in unusually good or poor condition, the model is often substantially wrong in a predictable direction.

On waterfront, the model struggles because water frontage, view quality and dock access vary enormously and are poorly captured in data.

On condos, the model rarely reflects building-specific issues such as assessments, reserves or insurance problems.

The pattern is consistent: the two agree where accuracy matters least and diverge where it matters most.

Why buyers still bring up the Zestimate

Buyers see it, and a number below your asking price becomes a negotiating point whether or not it is well founded.

Arguing that the model is wrong rarely persuades anyone, because it sounds like special pleading from the person selling.

Showing the actual comparable sales does persuade, because it replaces an opinion with evidence.

Having that package ready before you list turns a defensive conversation into a straightforward one.

The same package is useful with an appraiser, particularly where improvements are not visible in public data.

Preparation beats argument here, and the preparation is a document you should have anyway.

Keeping your property data accurate

Models read public records, so an error in the record propagates into the estimate and into buyers' expectations.

Check the recorded bedroom and bathroom count, square footage and lot size against reality, since errors are common.

Claiming your property on the major portals lets you correct some details and add information about improvements.

Permitted work is visible in records; unpermitted work is not, which is one of several reasons permits matter.

None of this will make an automated estimate authoritative, but it removes the avoidable errors.

It also means a buyer comparing the listing against the record does not find a discrepancy to ask about.

How to use both sensibly

Use an automated estimate as a rough orientation early on, when you are simply wondering whether selling is worth considering.

Use it to track broad direction over time, since the trend is more reliable than any single reading.

Do not use it to set an asking price, and be wary of any agent who agrees with it without showing their own analysis.

Use a CMA to set the price, and insist on seeing the comparables and the adjustments rather than only the conclusion.

If the two are far apart, that gap is worth understanding rather than ignoring, because a buyer will raise it.

Ask us for a CMA with the sales named and the adjustments explained, and compare it against whatever estimate you have been reading.

Questions to ask about any valuation

Which specific sales is this based on, and when did each of them close?

What adjustments were applied, and what evidence supports their size?

What is currently on the market that a buyer would consider instead of this property?

What would change this number, in either direction, and by roughly how much?

What price would you expect this to appraise at, given the same sales?

A valuation that cannot answer those five questions is a guess with a number attached, whoever produced it.

This page explains how the money side of a Florida sale works so you can plan around it. It is not legal or tax advice. Tax on your sale belongs with an accountant, and the legal effect of your contract belongs with a Florida attorney. What we can give you is an accurate figure for what your home is worth and what you would net, which is the input both of those conversations need.

Frequently Asked Questions

How accurate is a Zestimate?: Accuracy varies a great deal by area and property type, and the portals publish their own error figures. The useful figure is the error range rather than the median, because the properties where the model is least accurate tend to be exactly the ones that need careful pricing.
Why is my Zestimate lower than my agent's valuation?: Usually because the model cannot see condition, improvements or property-specific advantages. It works from public records, which do not record a renovated kitchen or a better view. Ask your agent to show the comparable sales behind their number so you can judge which is better supported.
Can I get my Zestimate changed?: You can claim the property on the portal and correct factual details such as bedroom count or square footage, which sometimes moves the estimate. You cannot have a number changed because you disagree with it. Correcting genuine record errors is worth doing regardless.
Should I price my home at the Zestimate?: No. It is a statistical estimate with a published error range, not an analysis of your property. Use it for rough orientation early on, then price from a comparative market analysis where you can see the sales and the adjustments.
Buyers keep citing the Zestimate. What do I say?: Show the comparable sales rather than arguing about the model. Evidence works where disputing the number does not, because a buyer reasonably discounts the seller's opinion. Having the package prepared before listing turns this into a short conversation.
Do appraisers use automated estimates?: No. An appraiser selects comparable sales and makes documented adjustments, much closer to a CMA than to a model. That is another reason to price from a CMA: it is the same method the appraisal will use, so it anticipates the constraint rather than colliding with it.
Which should I trust for a condo?: A CMA, by a wide margin. Automated models rarely capture building-specific factors such as pending assessments, reserve health, insurance difficulties or financing availability, and any of those can move a condo's value substantially. Those factors are exactly what a local analysis is for.
Why did my Zestimate change without anything happening?: Models update as new sales record nearby and as the underlying method is revised. A change usually reflects neighbourhood transactions rather than anything about your property. That is also why the trend over time is more informative than any single reading.
Should I worry if my Zestimate drops mid-listing?: Not in itself, though a buyer may raise it. The answer is the same as before: show the comparable sales rather than arguing about the model. A prepared package of recent sales settles the conversation faster than any explanation of how automated valuation works.
Do agents use automated estimates at all?: As a rough orientation when a seller first makes contact, and as a sense of what a buyer has probably already seen. Not to set a price. Any agent who agrees with an automated number without showing you their own comparable sales analysis has skipped the actual work.
Is a free online valuation the same as a CMA?: It depends entirely on what sits behind it. Some are automated estimates with a form attached. A genuine comparative market analysis names the sales it relies on, explains the adjustments and includes what is currently competing with you. Ask which you are being given.
Does an automated estimate affect my appraisal?: No. Appraisers select comparable sales and document adjustments, and they do not consult portal estimates. The estimate can affect buyer expectations and therefore the negotiation, which is a different problem and one that comparable sales evidence solves.
My neighbour has a higher estimate. Does that mean anything?: Only that the model read their property differently, often because of recorded square footage, bedroom count or a more recent nearby sale. It says nothing about what either property would actually sell for. Compare closed sales instead.

How to price your home to sell: reading comps properly

How to price your home to sell, using the comparable sales a listing agent actually relies on, and why the first two weeks decide what the rest of the sale looks like.

Sale-to-list ratio explained, and what it says about your price

Sale-to-list ratio explained for sellers: what the number measures, why a high one is not always good news, and how to use it when setting your asking price.

Best month to sell a house in South Florida

The best month to sell a house in South Florida depends on your buyer, not the calendar. How seasonal demand actually works here and when it favours your property.

From the Journal

Market Updates

Boca Raton home values: what the numbers actually say in 2026

Home Selling Tips

What Happens If the Appraisal Is Low in Florida? Options for Sellers

Home Selling Tips

Solar Panels and Home Value: Do They Help or Hurt When You Sell a South Florida Home?

Work out your numbers

What is my home worth?

A valuation built from closed sales in your own community, with the comparables named.

Estimate your net proceeds

Work the commission, documentary stamps and closing costs against your own number.

Current market reports

Prices, days on market and inventory for the counties we cover, updated monthly.

How we list a home

What we do between the listing agreement and the closing table, phase by phase.

Talk It Through

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what it is worth

Most of what makes a sale complicated is solvable once somebody has looked at the actual numbers. Onias Derilus is a licensed Florida broker and there is no cost to a conversation, whether you list this month or next year.

Get My Home Value Buying Too? Start Here

Keep Reading