Who is responsible for withholding?

In most cases the buyer is the withholding agent, and they must determine whether the seller is a foreign person. If they fail to withhold when required they can be held liable for the tax, which is why buyers and closing agents take it seriously.

Is it withheld on my profit or the sale price?

On the amount realized rather than on your gain, which is the part sellers find hardest. A seller with a small gain, or even a loss, can still face withholding. The difference is recovered through the return process rather than at closing.

Can the withholding be reduced?

In defined circumstances a withholding certificate can reduce it, but it must be applied for in advance and has its own timeline. Applying late generally means the withholding happens anyway. Whether you qualify is a tax adviser's assessment, not ours.

What is the residence exemption?

Where the amount realized does not exceed $300,000 and the buyer has definite plans to reside at the property for a defined proportion of days in each of the first two twelve-month periods, a full exemption can apply. It depends on the buyer, so it cannot be assumed at listing.

Do I need a US tax identification number?

You will generally need one, and obtaining it can take time if you do not already have it. That delay is a common cause of closing problems, which is why it belongs on the pre-listing list rather than the closing-week list.

Does Florida having no income tax help?

Not at all in this context. FIRPTA is federal and applies wherever in the United States the property sits. Assuming that Florida's lack of state income tax means no withholding is a common and expensive misunderstanding.

Will this affect my sale price?

Usually not. It is a process issue rather than a marketing one. What can affect the transaction is a buyer becoming nervous about their own liability, which an experienced closing agent settles quickly. Handled early it is purely administrative.

Can you tell me whether I am a foreign person?

No. That is a definitional question with real consequences and it belongs with a tax adviser experienced in cross-border property. What we can do is build the withholding into your net sheet so the proceeds figure you plan around is honest.

How long does it take to get the withheld amount back?

It is recovered through the return process rather than at closing, so it is months rather than weeks. That timing gap is the practical problem if you are relying on the proceeds to fund another purchase, which is why it belongs in the planning rather than the paperwork.

Does FIRPTA apply if I sell at a loss?

Withholding is calculated on the amount realized rather than on gain, so it can apply even where you made no profit at all. A withholding certificate is the route to address that in advance, and it has to be applied for before closing rather than afterwards.

FIRPTA: selling Florida property as a foreign seller

FIRPTA withholding when selling Florida property applies where the seller is a foreign person, and it catches people out because the money is withheld at closing rather than settled later. The general rate is 15% of the amount realized, and the buyer is normally the withholding agent. Planning for it before closing is the entire point.

Free Home Valuation

Every situation on this page comes down to a number: what the property is worth and what you would net. We will work both out from recent sales near you, at no cost.

What FIRPTA does

It requires withholding on the disposition of a US real property interest by a foreign person.

The withholding is taken at closing from the amount realized rather than billed afterwards.

It is a collection mechanism rather than the final tax, and the actual liability is settled on a return.

That means the amount withheld can exceed what is ultimately owed, and a refund process exists.

The general rate is 15% of the amount realized, which comes from the IRS FIRPTA withholding guidance.

Whether you are a foreign person for these purposes is a definitional question for a tax adviser.

Who actually withholds

In most cases the buyer is the withholding agent, which surprises buyers as often as sellers.

The buyer has to determine whether the seller is a foreign person.

If the buyer fails to withhold when they should have, they can be held liable for the tax.

That liability is why buyers and their closing agents take this seriously.

Where a business entity disposes of the property, the entity can be the withholding agent.

In practice the closing agent administers the mechanics, but the legal responsibility sits with the transferee.

The residence exemption

A complete exemption can apply where the amount realized does not exceed $300,000 and the buyer intends to use the property as a residence.

The buyer must have definite plans to reside at the property for a defined proportion of the days in each of the first two twelve-month periods after transfer.

That is a requirement about the buyer rather than about you, which means it depends on who buys.

Because it depends on the buyer's intention, it cannot be assumed at listing.

A reduced rate can also apply in a band above that threshold, and the figure for that band should come from your tax adviser rather than from a brokerage page.

The thresholds and conditions come from IRS guidance, which is public and worth reading with your adviser.

Why it affects your net

Withholding comes out of the proceeds at closing, so the amount you receive on the day is reduced.

It is calculated on the amount realized rather than on your gain, which is the part sellers find hardest.

A seller with a small gain, or a loss, can still face withholding on the full amount realized.

The difference is recovered through the return process rather than at closing.

That timing gap matters if you are relying on proceeds to fund a purchase.

Planning for it in the net sheet prevents a closing day surprise.

Reducing or avoiding the withholding

A withholding certificate can, in defined circumstances, reduce the amount withheld.

It is applied for in advance and has its own process and timeline.

Applying late generally means the withholding happens anyway and the difference is recovered later.

Whether you qualify, and whether it is worth the effort, is a tax adviser's assessment.

The application needs to be underway well before closing rather than in the final week.

Start this conversation before you list, because the timeline is the constraint.

What you need before closing

A determination of your status, which is definitional and should come from a tax adviser.

A US taxpayer identification number, which can take time to obtain if you do not have one.

Documentation for the closing agent so the mechanics can be handled correctly.

A decision on whether to pursue a withholding certificate.

A net sheet reflecting the withholding, so the proceeds figure is realistic.

The identification number is a common cause of delay, which is why it belongs on the pre-listing list.

How it interacts with the rest of the sale

Buyers are sometimes nervous about their own liability, which a well-informed closing agent settles quickly.

Experienced closing agents handle FIRPTA routinely, so choosing one who does matters.

Disclosing the position early in the transaction avoids a late complication.

It does not usually affect price, though it can affect a buyer's comfort if handled badly.

It is very much a process issue rather than a marketing one.

Handled openly and early it is administrative. Discovered late it is a closing problem.

State and federal are separate

FIRPTA is federal and applies wherever in the United States the property is.

Florida has no state personal income tax, which does not affect the federal withholding at all.

Your home country may also tax the sale, and treaty positions can matter.

Those interactions are specialist territory and need an adviser familiar with both sides.

Assuming Florida's lack of income tax means no withholding is a common and expensive mistake.

The two subjects are unconnected other than by coincidence of timing.

What we do and do not do

We ask about seller status at the listing appointment, because it affects planning.

We recommend closing agents who handle FIRPTA transactions routinely.

We build the withholding into the net sheet so the proceeds figure is honest.

We flag it to the buyer's side early so nobody is surprised near closing.

We do not determine status, calculate withholding or advise on certificates.

Those belong with a tax adviser experienced in cross-border property, and we will say so.

The order that works

Confirm your status with a tax adviser before listing.

Obtain a taxpayer identification number if you do not already have one, because it takes time.

Decide early whether a withholding certificate is worth pursuing.

Choose a closing agent experienced with FIRPTA.

Get a net sheet that reflects the withholding rather than one that ignores it.

Ask us for the valuation and net sheet and we will build the withholding into the figures.

This page explains how the money side of a Florida sale works so you can plan around it. It is not legal or tax advice. Tax on your sale belongs with an accountant, and the legal effect of your contract belongs with a Florida attorney. What we can give you is an accurate figure for what your home is worth and what you would net, which is the input both of those conversations need.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is FIRPTA?: A federal requirement to withhold on the disposition of a US real property interest by a foreign person. The withholding is taken at closing from the amount realized rather than billed later, and it is a collection mechanism rather than the final tax liability.
What is the withholding rate?: The general rate is 15% of the amount realized, according to IRS FIRPTA guidance. A complete exemption can apply where the amount realized does not exceed $300,000 and the buyer has definite plans to use the property as a residence.
Who is responsible for withholding?: In most cases the buyer is the withholding agent, and they must determine whether the seller is a foreign person. If they fail to withhold when required they can be held liable for the tax, which is why buyers and closing agents take it seriously.
Is it withheld on my profit or the sale price?: On the amount realized rather than on your gain, which is the part sellers find hardest. A seller with a small gain, or even a loss, can still face withholding. The difference is recovered through the return process rather than at closing.
Can the withholding be reduced?: In defined circumstances a withholding certificate can reduce it, but it must be applied for in advance and has its own timeline. Applying late generally means the withholding happens anyway. Whether you qualify is a tax adviser's assessment, not ours.
What is the residence exemption?: Where the amount realized does not exceed $300,000 and the buyer has definite plans to reside at the property for a defined proportion of days in each of the first two twelve-month periods, a full exemption can apply. It depends on the buyer, so it cannot be assumed at listing.
Do I need a US tax identification number?: You will generally need one, and obtaining it can take time if you do not already have it. That delay is a common cause of closing problems, which is why it belongs on the pre-listing list rather than the closing-week list.
Does Florida having no income tax help?: Not at all in this context. FIRPTA is federal and applies wherever in the United States the property sits. Assuming that Florida's lack of state income tax means no withholding is a common and expensive misunderstanding.
Will this affect my sale price?: Usually not. It is a process issue rather than a marketing one. What can affect the transaction is a buyer becoming nervous about their own liability, which an experienced closing agent settles quickly. Handled early it is purely administrative.
Can you tell me whether I am a foreign person?: No. That is a definitional question with real consequences and it belongs with a tax adviser experienced in cross-border property. What we can do is build the withholding into your net sheet so the proceeds figure you plan around is honest.
How long does it take to get the withheld amount back?: It is recovered through the return process rather than at closing, so it is months rather than weeks. That timing gap is the practical problem if you are relying on the proceeds to fund another purchase, which is why it belongs in the planning rather than the paperwork.
Does FIRPTA apply if I sell at a loss?: Withholding is calculated on the amount realized rather than on gain, so it can apply even where you made no profit at all. A withholding certificate is the route to address that in advance, and it has to be applied for before closing rather than afterwards.

Capital gains tax on a home sale: the exclusion

Capital gains tax on a home sale: how the $250,000 and $500,000 exclusion works, the ownership and use tests, and what raises your basis.

1031 exchange for investment property sellers

A 1031 exchange can defer gain on an investment property sale. What the structure requires, why the deadlines are unforgiving, and who has to be involved.

Prorated property taxes at closing in Florida

Prorated property taxes at closing in Florida: why you owe tax you thought was paid, how the proration is calculated, and what appears on your statement.

From the Journal

Home Selling Tips

Selling to International Buyers in Palm Beach County: Pricing, Currency, Remote Closings and FIRPTA

Work out your numbers

What is my home worth?

A valuation built from closed sales in your own community, with the comparables named.

Estimate your net proceeds

Work the commission, documentary stamps and closing costs against your own number.

Current market reports

Prices, days on market and inventory for the counties we cover, updated monthly.

How we list a home

What we do between the listing agreement and the closing table, phase by phase.

Talk It Through

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what it is worth

Most of what makes a sale complicated is solvable once somebody has looked at the actual numbers. Onias Derilus is a licensed Florida broker and there is no cost to a conversation, whether you list this month or next year.

Get My Home Value Buying Too? Start Here

Keep Reading