What is a short sale?

A sale where the proceeds fall short of the loan balance and the lender agrees to release its lien anyway. The lender is not obliged to agree, and that approval is the central uncertainty. It is not the same as foreclosure, where the lender takes the property.

How long does a short sale take?

Longer than an ordinary sale, with the extra time sitting entirely with the lender. More than one lien holder means more than one approval. Requests for updated documents are common and reset progress if not answered quickly, so responsiveness matters.

Do I pay anything at closing?

Usually not, because lenders typically approve the costs of sale out of the proceeds. The real costs are time, uncertainty, credit consequences and possible tax treatment of forgiven debt. Those are questions for a counsellor, attorney and accountant respectively.

Will I still owe the difference?

It depends on the approval and the circumstances, and it is precisely why a Florida attorney should review the approval letter before you accept it. Do not assume a short sale automatically extinguishes the shortfall, because that is not always how it works.

Is a short sale better than foreclosure?

It generally gives more control over timing and process, and many sellers prefer it for that reason. Whether it is better for you depends on your circumstances, including credit and tax consequences. A HUD-approved counsellor can compare the options at no cost.

Why do short sales fall through?

Most often because the buyer loses patience and walks, which means restarting much of the process. Other common causes are incomplete documentation, a second lien holder who will not agree, and a lender valuation well above the offer price.

What kind of buyer should I look for?

One who understands the timeline and will wait, which usually means investors and experienced purchasers rather than first-time buyers. An offer near market value from a patient buyer is worth considerably more than a higher offer that will not survive the wait.

Does my lender have to approve it?

Yes, and they are not obliged to. They will want documented hardship, financial information, evidence of genuine marketing, a signed contract and their own valuation. The lender's valuation disagreeing with the offer is a common reason approval is refused.

Can I do a short sale if I have a second mortgage?

It is possible and materially harder, because each lien holder has to agree. Second lien holders often receive very little in a short sale, which gives them less incentive to approve. Establish early whether a second lien exists, because it changes the difficulty.

Should I try a short sale first?

Not necessarily. Speak to a HUD-approved counsellor before assuming it is the answer, because reinstatement, a repayment plan, forbearance or a modification may suit you better. A short sale is for cases where the numbers genuinely do not work.

Can I choose my own buyer in a short sale?

You accept an offer as you would in any sale, but the lender has to approve both the price and the terms, so your acceptance is conditional. An offer you would happily take can still be declined if the lender's own valuation does not support it.

What happens if the lender rejects the offer?

You can submit a revised offer, market for a higher one, or consider a different route entirely. Rejection usually reflects the lender's valuation rather than anything about the buyer, so understanding what figure they are working to is the useful next question.

The short sale process for sellers in Florida

The short sale process for sellers begins where an ordinary sale stops working: the property is worth less than the loan against it, so the lender has to agree to accept less than the full balance. That agreement is the whole transaction. Everything else, including the buyer, is secondary to whether the lender says yes.

Free Home Valuation

Every situation on this page comes down to a number: what the property is worth and what you would net. We will work both out from recent sales near you, at no cost.

What a short sale is

A sale where the proceeds fall short of the loan balance and the lender agrees to release its lien anyway.

The lender is not obliged to agree, and approval is the central uncertainty in the whole process.

It is not the same as foreclosure, which is the lender taking the property rather than approving a sale.

It is also not automatic relief from the remaining debt, which is a separate question entirely.

Whether any shortfall is pursued afterwards depends on the agreement and on the circumstances.

That last point is why an attorney should review the approval letter before you accept it.

What the lender will want

Evidence of hardship, usually documented rather than described.

Financial information including income, assets and liabilities.

A listing agreement and evidence the property has been genuinely marketed.

A signed purchase contract from a buyer prepared to wait.

A settlement statement showing exactly what the lender would receive.

Their own valuation of the property, which they commission and which can disagree with yours.

How long it really takes

Longer than an ordinary sale, and the additional time sits entirely with the lender rather than the market.

More than one lien holder means more than one approval, and a second mortgage frequently complicates matters.

Mortgage insurance, where it exists, can add another party whose agreement is needed.

Requests for updated documents are common and reset progress if they are not answered quickly.

Buyers lose patience, and losing a buyer means restarting much of the process.

Setting realistic expectations at the start is the single most useful thing you can do.

Finding a buyer who will wait

The property must be genuinely marketed, because the lender wants evidence of market value.

Buyers need to understand that approval is uncertain and the timeline is not in anyone's control.

Investors and experienced buyers handle this better than first-time purchasers.

An offer well below market may be rejected by the lender even if you would accept it.

An offer near market value with a patient buyer is worth more than a higher offer that will not wait.

Losing a buyer partway through is the most common reason a short sale fails.

What it costs you

Usually no cash at closing, because the lender typically approves costs out of the proceeds.

Time, which is the main cost, and uncertainty throughout.

Credit consequences, which are real and are a question for a counsellor or attorney.

Possible tax consequences where debt is forgiven, which is an accountant's question.

Possible continued liability for a shortfall depending on what the approval says.

None of those are reasons not to do it. They are reasons to get advice before starting.

Short sale against the alternatives

Against foreclosure, a short sale generally gives you more control over timing and process.

Against a conventional sale, it is slower and less certain, so it is only for cases where the numbers do not work.

Against a deed in lieu, the trade-offs differ and the right answer depends on your circumstances.

Against keeping the property through a modification, it depends entirely on whether the loan can be made affordable.

A HUD-approved counsellor can walk through all of these at no cost.

Start there rather than assuming a short sale is the answer, because sometimes it is not.

Where it usually goes wrong

Starting too late, when a foreclosure timetable is already running.

Incomplete documentation, which stalls the file without anyone announcing it.

A buyer who walks, which is the most common single failure.

A second lien holder who will not agree, which can stop everything.

A lender valuation well above the offer, which makes approval unlikely at that price.

Most of these are manageable with preparation and responsiveness, which is most of what the process requires.

What we do in a short sale

We value the property honestly, because a lender's own valuation will test ours.

We market it genuinely, since evidence of real marketing is part of what the lender assesses.

We prepare buyers for the timeline so they are less likely to walk halfway through.

We keep the documentation moving, because stalled files are usually stalled on paperwork.

We tell you plainly when a short sale is not the right route for your situation.

We do not negotiate with the lender on legal matters, and we will say when you need an attorney.

Who else you need

A Florida attorney to review the approval letter, particularly any language about the remaining balance.

An accountant for the tax treatment of forgiven debt.

A HUD-approved housing counsellor for the free, independent overview of all options.

Your lender or servicer, who holds the process and the figures.

A closing agent experienced with short sales, because the paperwork differs from an ordinary closing.

Assembling this group early is what makes the process survivable.

Before you start

Get the payoff figure and an honest valuation, and confirm the shortfall actually exists.

Check whether there is a second lien, because it changes the difficulty considerably.

Speak to a counsellor about whether a short sale is the best of your available options.

Understand the credit and tax consequences before committing rather than afterwards.

Be ready to respond to document requests quickly, because delay is the main enemy.

Ask us for the valuation and net sheet, and we will tell you honestly whether this is the route.

This page explains how the money side of a Florida sale works so you can plan around it. It is not legal or tax advice. Tax on your sale belongs with an accountant, and the legal effect of your contract belongs with a Florida attorney. What we can give you is an accurate figure for what your home is worth and what you would net, which is the input both of those conversations need.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a short sale?: A sale where the proceeds fall short of the loan balance and the lender agrees to release its lien anyway. The lender is not obliged to agree, and that approval is the central uncertainty. It is not the same as foreclosure, where the lender takes the property.
How long does a short sale take?: Longer than an ordinary sale, with the extra time sitting entirely with the lender. More than one lien holder means more than one approval. Requests for updated documents are common and reset progress if not answered quickly, so responsiveness matters.
Do I pay anything at closing?: Usually not, because lenders typically approve the costs of sale out of the proceeds. The real costs are time, uncertainty, credit consequences and possible tax treatment of forgiven debt. Those are questions for a counsellor, attorney and accountant respectively.
Will I still owe the difference?: It depends on the approval and the circumstances, and it is precisely why a Florida attorney should review the approval letter before you accept it. Do not assume a short sale automatically extinguishes the shortfall, because that is not always how it works.
Is a short sale better than foreclosure?: It generally gives more control over timing and process, and many sellers prefer it for that reason. Whether it is better for you depends on your circumstances, including credit and tax consequences. A HUD-approved counsellor can compare the options at no cost.
Why do short sales fall through?: Most often because the buyer loses patience and walks, which means restarting much of the process. Other common causes are incomplete documentation, a second lien holder who will not agree, and a lender valuation well above the offer price.
What kind of buyer should I look for?: One who understands the timeline and will wait, which usually means investors and experienced purchasers rather than first-time buyers. An offer near market value from a patient buyer is worth considerably more than a higher offer that will not survive the wait.
Does my lender have to approve it?: Yes, and they are not obliged to. They will want documented hardship, financial information, evidence of genuine marketing, a signed contract and their own valuation. The lender's valuation disagreeing with the offer is a common reason approval is refused.
Can I do a short sale if I have a second mortgage?: It is possible and materially harder, because each lien holder has to agree. Second lien holders often receive very little in a short sale, which gives them less incentive to approve. Establish early whether a second lien exists, because it changes the difficulty.
Should I try a short sale first?: Not necessarily. Speak to a HUD-approved counsellor before assuming it is the answer, because reinstatement, a repayment plan, forbearance or a modification may suit you better. A short sale is for cases where the numbers genuinely do not work.
Can I choose my own buyer in a short sale?: You accept an offer as you would in any sale, but the lender has to approve both the price and the terms, so your acceptance is conditional. An offer you would happily take can still be declined if the lender's own valuation does not support it.
What happens if the lender rejects the offer?: You can submit a revised offer, market for a higher one, or consider a different route entirely. Rejection usually reflects the lender's valuation rather than anything about the buyer, so understanding what figure they are working to is the useful next question.

Behind on mortgage payments: options before foreclosure

Behind on mortgage payments in Florida: what selling looks like as an option, how equity changes the picture, and why acting early preserves choices.

Selling a house with code liens or municipal fines

Selling a house with code liens: how municipal fines attach to the property, what mitigation involves, and how to clear them before a closing date slips.

Selling a hoarder house or a heavy-repair property

Selling a hoarder house: clearing, cleaning and deciding between an as-is investor sale and preparing for the open market, with the arithmetic behind each.

From the Journal

Home Selling Tips

Short Sale Pros and Cons in Florida: How They Work and How Long They Take

Home Selling Tips

Short Sale, Deed in Lieu or Foreclosure in Florida: Credit Damage and How Soon You Can Buy Again

Home Buying Tips

Risks of Buying a Short Sale Home in South Florida

Work out your numbers

What is my home worth?

A valuation built from closed sales in your own community, with the comparables named.

Estimate your net proceeds

Work the commission, documentary stamps and closing costs against your own number.

Current market reports

Prices, days on market and inventory for the counties we cover, updated monthly.

How we list a home

What we do between the listing agreement and the closing table, phase by phase.

Talk It Through

Tell us the situation and we will tell you what it is worth

Most of what makes a sale complicated is solvable once somebody has looked at the actual numbers. Onias Derilus is a licensed Florida broker and there is no cost to a conversation, whether you list this month or next year.

Get My Home Value Buying Too? Start Here

Keep Reading