Loading…
Loading…
Community · Cutler Bay, FL
Cutler Cay is a community in Cutler Bay, Miami-Dade County, Florida. Active listings are priced from $840,000 to $2,200,000.
Get Pre-Approved →Get Listings Alerts
Be the first to know when a new home hits the market in Cutler Cay.
Cutler Cay Market at a Glance
Live MLS · Updated Aug 30, 2026
Residential MLS data for Cutler Cay, updated nightly. View full market reports →
Available Now
Market Overview
There are 26 active listings for sale in Cutler Cay right now. The median list price is $1,094,500, or about $280 per square foot. Listings span $789,000 to $2,200,000, so there is inventory across most budgets. Homes are averaging 117 days on market. These figures update from the MLS as the market moves.
Cutler Cay Market Stats
Live MLSFrequently Asked Questions
About Cutler Cay
Cutler Cay is a community in Cutler Bay, Miami-Dade County, Florida. Active listings are priced from $840,000 to $2,200,000. Homes were built between 2004 and 2007. Pure Equity Realty lists homes in Cutler Cay for 1% commission and represents buyers at no cost.
Homes & Architecture
Homes for sale in Cutler Cay offer 4 to 5 bedrooms and 3.5 to 5.5 baths. Living areas run from about 2,723 to 4,717 square feet. The mix here includes single family homes. Current prices run from $789,000 to $2,200,000. The homes on the market were built between 2005 and 2007.
Schools
Homes for sale in Cutler Cay are typically zoned for the Cutler Bay public schools below, based on current MLS listings. Confirm the exact attendance zone for any specific address with the Miami-Dade County school district before you buy.
Market & Value
Values in Cutler Cay track the community's own sales more closely than any broad regional number. The median list price in Cutler Cay is around $1,094,500, or roughly $280 per square foot. That sits about 83% above the Miami-Dade County median, which shows where Cutler Cay lands in the local market. Recent asking prices have run from $789,000 to $2,200,000, so the home you choose within Cutler Cay matters as much as the community average. Homes here have recently taken about 117 days to go under contract, a useful gauge of how quickly the Cutler Cay market is moving. For pricing an offer or a listing, comparable sales within Cutler Cay carry more weight than any headline number, since homes of the same type and size set the real range. Pure Equity Realty can pull the active and recently sold homes in Cutler Cay so you work from real numbers, not an estimate.
Who It Suits
A quick read on who fits Cutler Cay saves time before you visit. Cutler Cay suits a range of buyers, from first-time owners to move-up families, who want a home in Cutler Bay with the everyday conveniences of the area close by. On price, Cutler Cay sits in the upper tier, drawing buyers who want more space, newer construction, or a stronger location. Whether Cutler Cay is right for you depends on how you plan to use the home, full time or seasonally, and Pure Equity Realty can walk you through the tradeoffs before you commit.
Amenities & Lifestyle
Cutler Cay is a residential neighborhood, and its homeowners association maintains the shared areas and community standards.
Location
Cutler Cay is located in Cutler Bay, part of Miami-Dade County, Florida. Residents are close to the shopping, dining, schools, and parks of the Cutler Bay area, with the wider job centers, beaches, and airports of the region within driving distance.
Buying in Cutler Cay
Buying in Cutler Cay follows the same path as the rest of Miami-Dade County. Getting a mortgage pre-approval first tells you your real budget and lets you move quickly when the right home comes up. Property taxes factor into the monthly payment: the median annual property tax in Miami-Dade County is about $3,516. Florida's homestead exemption lowers the taxable value of a primary residence, and the Save Our Homes cap limits how fast that assessed value can rise from year to year. Budget for homeowners insurance as well. Rates in Florida reflect wind and flood exposure, so gather quotes early and check whether a specific address sits in a FEMA flood zone. Once you are under contract, plan for a home inspection and, if you are financing, a lender appraisal, both of which fall inside the inspection period. Working with an agent who knows Cutler Bay means you see new listings in Cutler Cay the day they reach the market.
Selling in Cutler Cay
A successful sale in Cutler Cay comes down to pricing, presentation, and marketing. List prices in Cutler Cay currently center around $1,094,500, which is a starting reference for where a comparable home might be positioned. Homes that are decluttered, professionally photographed, and priced to recent comparable sales tend to draw the most interest in the first two weeks, when a listing is newest and gets the most views. Florida sellers usually pay the documentary stamp tax on the deed, currently $0.70 per $100 of the sale price in most counties, along with prorated property taxes and, by local custom in many areas, the owner's title insurance policy. We provide a no-obligation home valuation for Cutler Cay owners in Cutler Bay, so you can see what your property could sell for before you commit to listing.
Public Records
Anything on this page that affects what a home costs to own, assessed value, exemptions, flood zone, is published by a public agency. These are the official sources, not our summaries of them.
Miami-Dade County Property Appraiser
Assessed value, homestead exemption status, and recorded sales history for any parcel.
FEMA Flood Map Service Center
Look up the official flood zone for an address before you budget for insurance.
Florida Department of Revenue, property taxes
How Florida assesses property, and which exemptions you can claim.
More Communities in Cutler Bay
The Courts At Bayshore
Condominium
Bel Aire
Community
Le Club At Old Cutler Con
Condominium
Lakes By The Bay
55+ Community
Cutler Ridge
Community
Whispering Pines Est Sec
Community
Enclave South
Community
Lakes By The Bay Gee
55+ Community
Benson Manor
Community
Paradise Pointe
Condominium
Saga Bay Townhomes
Community
Lakes By The Bay Cee
55+ Community
Nearby Communities in Miami-Dade County
